User Access Review Checklist, Template, and Policy
A user access review checklist helps you confirm that access still matches a legitimate business need and follow required changes through to completion. It gives everyone involved a shared process for preparing the review, making decisions and documenting the outcome.
If you're responsible for the review, collecting approvals is only part of the work. You also need to know whether application exports cover the right accounts, whether reviewers have enough context to decide and whether requested removals actually happened. A completed spreadsheet can leave those questions unanswered. The review record needs to connect what was in scope, who made each decision and the verified result.
Use the before, during and after checklist below to organize that work, and the copyable review table to record it. Separate downloads include an Excel workbook, a policy template and reviewer email templates, ready to adapt to your systems and responsibilities. For an introduction to the process, see what user access reviews are.
Download the templates:
User access review checklist#
Before the review#
- Name the control owner. Assign responsibility for scope, deadlines, unresolved decisions and final sign-off.
- Define the population. List systems, entitlements and identity types, including employees, contractors, privileged accounts and separately owned service or agent identities. Document exclusions and why they are acceptable.
- Capture the source data. Record each export's source, extraction time and account or grant count. Preserve the original snapshot alongside the working review.
- Reconcile coverage. Compare the review population with application inventories and relevant identity records. Investigate missing accounts, duplicates and unmatched owners. HR records help identify people; service accounts need an accountable business or technical owner.
- Assign qualified reviewers. Give managers business context and application owners entitlement context. Set an independent reviewer for a person's own access and a fallback when the assigned reviewer is unavailable.
- Set expectations. Establish the review deadline, remediation deadlines by risk, escalation route and evidence location. Explain the decision choices before opening the campaign.
A matching row count does not prove completeness. If an application export contains 240 grants and the review contains 237, resolve the difference. If both contain 240, still check whether the same accounts and grants appear in each.
During the review#
- Confirm identity and ownership. Check employment or contract status, current role, account type and accountable owner. Investigate orphaned accounts.
- Assess the entitlement. Confirm the business need, privilege level and any conflicting permissions. Trace direct grants, group membership and inherited access so the reviewer understands how access is obtained.
- Use context carefully. Consider available activity and prior decisions. A recent sign-in does not establish that every entitlement is needed; missing activity data does not prove access is unused.
- Record a decision for each grant. Use Keep, Change, Remove or Investigate. Capture the reviewer, decision date and rationale. For Change, specify the required replacement access.
- Resolve uncertainty. Assign an owner and deadline to investigations. Record any approved exception with its reason, risk, approver, compensating measures and expiry. Silence is not approval.
After the review#
- Assign the changes. Link every Change or Remove decision to a remediation task with an implementation owner and due date.
- Verify the outcome. Check the target system after implementation. Confirm that other groups or access paths do not still provide the access being removed. Record who verified the result, when and where the evidence is stored.
- Escalate overdue work. Track overdue decisions and remediation separately. An approved removal that remains unimplemented is still open work.
- Record sign-off. Summarize coverage, decisions, completed changes and outstanding exceptions. Have the control owner accept any residual risk through the organization's approval process.
- Preserve the evidence. Retain the population snapshot, reconciliation, decisions, changes, exceptions and sign-off under the applicable retention policy. Schedule the next review and track expiring exceptions.
Copyable user access review template#
Download: User access review workbook (Excel)
Use one row per account, system, entitlement and access path. The same person may need several rows. Give each row a stable review ID so decisions remain connected to remediation even when a spreadsheet is sorted or split between reviewers.
Start each campaign with this scope record:
| Scope field | Complete before launch |
|---|---|
| Campaign and control owner | [Campaign ID; name and contact] |
| Scope and exclusions | [Systems, identity types, entitlements; exclusions and rationale] |
| Review period and deadline | [Period covered; decision deadline] |
| Population source | [Export source, extraction timestamp and snapshot location per system] |
| Reconciliation | [Source count and unit; review count; differences and resolution] |
| Reviewers and fallback | [Assignments; independent reviewer; fallback contact] |
| Evidence and sign-off | [Restricted evidence location; sign-off owner and date] |
The table below is a compact version of the review register. The workbook separates the fields into columns for filtering, with Access review, Campaign scope and Instructions tabs. If copying this table into your own spreadsheet, separate the grouped details into columns. The sample is fictional.
| Review ID | Account and owner | System, entitlement and access path | Context | Reviewer and decision | Remediation | Verification |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| [Stable ID] | [Account; identity type; accountable owner] | [System; resource; entitlement; direct/group/inherited path] | [Role or purpose; risk; available activity; unknowns] | [Reviewer; Keep/Change/Remove/Investigate; rationale; date] | [Task ID; implementation owner; due date; status; execution date] | [Verifier; verification date; outcome; evidence link or exception ID] |
| UAR-042 | a.lee; employee; Maya Chen | Finance app; production; administrator; Finance-Admins group | Transferred to analyst role; administrator access no longer needed | Ravi Shah; Remove; role change; Nov 3 | CHG-1042; IT operations; due Nov 5; open; not executed | Pending; no completion evidence yet |
For UAR-042, a Remove decision starts the follow-up task. After IT removes the group membership, the verifier checks the account's effective access in the finance application. Record the verifier, verification date, outcome and evidence separately from the remediation status. If another group still grants administrator access, keep the task open and address that path too.
Record exceptions with the review ID, approver, expiry and follow-up owner, using the workbook’s exception fields or a linked register. Do not overwrite the original decision to make an unresolved item look complete.
User access review policy template#
Adapt the policy to your systems, review schedule, responsibilities and evidence requirements. Have your security and compliance teams review it before adoption.
User access review email templates#
The document includes kickoff, reminder and overdue messages. Customize the scope, deadlines and support contacts, and link reviewers to a restricted workspace.
Adapt the templates for SOX, HIPAA and ISO 27001#
These frameworks have different scopes. Use the templates to document your chosen controls; a completed workbook does not establish compliance.
| Framework | How to tailor the review |
|---|---|
| SOX | Identify systems and permissions relevant to internal control over financial reporting, such as access affecting financial records or conflicting duties. Retain evidence supporting your control's design and operation. Section 404's annual management assessment does not create a universal quarterly access-review mandate. See the SEC's Section 404 guidance. |
| HIPAA | Covered entities and business associates should scope access to electronic protected health information. Access-rights procedures, required regular information-system activity review and periodic security evaluation are separate provisions in 45 CFR 164.308. Access establishment and modification is an addressable specification. Addressable requires assessment and appropriate documented action; it does not mean optional. See HHS's explanation. |
| ISO/IEC 27001 | Align review scope, responsibilities and schedule with the ISMS, risk treatment and applicable controls recorded in the Statement of Applicability. ISO/IEC 27001 is a standard, not legislation; ISO/IEC 27001:2022 defines ISMS requirements and ISO/IEC 27002:2022 provides control guidance. Confirm detailed requirements against your licensed standards. |
Frequently asked questions#
How often should user access reviews happen?#
Set the frequency by access risk, system sensitivity, applicable obligations and your control design. Document the schedule in policy and reassess access after relevant lifecycle events; do not assume one interval fits every system.
Who should perform a user access review?#
Choose reviewers who can judge business need and entitlement suitability, often managers and application owners. Assign someone independent to review each reviewer's own access, and provide a fallback when a reviewer is unavailable or conflicted.
What evidence should a user access review retain?#
Retain the scoped population and reconciliation, named decisions with rationale and dates, verified changes, approved exceptions and sign-off. Preserve enough detail to connect each decision to its final outcome.
How should service accounts and AI agents be reviewed?#
Assign an accountable owner who can explain each identity's purpose, permissions and continued need. Include those identities in scope even when they have no HR record, and investigate missing ownership before approving continued access.
What happens when a reviewer cannot decide?#
Record Investigate, the missing information, an owner and a deadline. Escalate unresolved items or document an authorized, time-limited exception under policy instead of treating uncertainty as approval.
Carry decisions through to verified changes#
As review scope grows, coordinating exports, reviewers and remediation can become the hardest part. C1.ai, formerly ConductorOne, supports identity governance and administration workflows that help teams scope campaigns, route reviews and track remediation and evidence. The context available and changes C1.ai can automate depend on your integrations and configuration; some changes require manual fulfillment.
Explore user access review automation with C1.ai to see how those workflows can support your review process.


