The Business Case for IGA Modernization
At the budget meeting, put the last quarterly access review beside the renewal quote. Take one decision to remove access. Someone assembled the records, found the application owner and followed up until the owner made a decision. Someone still had to check that access was gone. Those hours help explain why two proposals with similar subscription prices can cost different amounts to operate.
To calculate the cash return on IGA modernization, compare the cost of delivering the same identity governance and administration controls over a stated period. When modernization requires additional upfront investment, IGA ROI is the operating cash savings less that investment, divided by the investment. Run the numbers against today's costs and a credible improvement to the existing platform.
PriceSmart brought access data from JD Edwards, AWS and Azure into one review process. Previously, its team had combined records in spreadsheets, distributed reviews by email and checked afterward that decisions followed policy. In C1.ai, multistep policies used attributes such as role and location to route decisions to the right manager or application owner during the review. PriceSmart reported that quarterly reviews went from three months to two or three weeks. To forecast a cash return from a shorter campaign, trace the work it eliminates to a payment you can reduce. PriceSmart's access review story
What would it cost to improve the platform you own?#
Suppose the identity and access management (IAM) team spent much of its last campaign forwarding decisions to the right person. Cleaning up ownership records and configuring routing in the platform it already licenses might solve that problem. Its proposal should price the configuration work, the upkeep when ownership changes and the specialist hours each campaign will still require.
The C1 proposal needs to cover the same applications, people and accounts, with the same review frequency, approvals, removal deadline and evidence requirements. Have both teams demonstrate your hardest application and review policy. If coverage differs, request prices for the common scope. A pilot on one application can reveal how much work its review takes. If forty others share the infrastructure, the hosting bill depends on what happens to those applications too.
Procurement can establish when cash savings would start by checking renewal and cancellation terms. A consultant who bills by the hour, a prepaid block of hours and an annual support agreement can carry the same budget label and produce three different cash forecasts. Ask for an itemized subscription and services quote for each option, including connector work and any support that continues after rollout. For a SailPoint renewal, use C1's pricing guide to prepare questions for the quote. C1's SailPoint pricing guide · C1's guide to identity governance software costs
An IGA ROI worksheet for the renewal decision#
Copy the table into your funding request. For each option, enter the amount, unit, effective date and source record in its blank column. Use annual dollars for recurring spend, dated payments for one-time costs and hours per campaign for staff effort. Split contracts into separate lines when their dates differ. Count each payment once. If the services contract covers connector support or training, break out the item only if you can subtract it from the contract total. Likewise, enter overlap once and assign each hour of audit support to one activity.
| Driver | Who supplies the figure and how to measure it | Current | Improved incumbent | C1 proposal |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Subscription and support | Procurement, contracted module fees and renewal or exit dates | |||
| Hosting | Infrastructure, billed resources × rate through last charge | |||
| External services | IAM, committed hours × rate or fixed fee and reduction date | |||
| Connector setup and maintenance | App owners, quoted build and support costs and start dates | |||
| Data preparation and validation | IAM and control owners, hours or supplier fees through testing | |||
| Training and transition | Project lead, sessions × rate and payment dates | |||
| Subscription overlap | Procurement, extra monthly fee × months both contracts are payable | |||
| Reviews and exceptions | IAM and app owners, campaign hours by role and manual follow-ups | |||
| Audit preparation | Compliance team, evidence requests × hours per request | |||
| Outstanding revocations | Control owner, overdue removals at deadline and days until verified closure |
A lower invoice belongs in the cash forecast from the date the commitment falls. Avoiding a future purchase, such as a planned contractor extension, needs a different piece of evidence. Identify which alternative would incur the expense and count the approved purchase or forecast once in that alternative.
Faster reviews can also give time back to people on payroll. Cutting effort from 120 to 60 hours on each of four annual campaigns releases 240 hours a year. At a loaded rate of $75 an hour, that is $18,000 of capacity at steady state. The IAM manager might use those hours to bring a backlog of applications into review. The cash forecast below counts only changes to payments.
What the three-year numbers tell Finance#
The fictional three-year schedule begins at rollout approval, after a one-application pilot. All figures are US dollars. Pilot costs already paid are sunk and excluded from both forward alternatives. For a decision before the pilot, start the clock at evaluation, include its duration and incremental supplier payments, and deduct any pilot fees credited to rollout.
Both proposals cover the same applications and controls. The model assumes equivalent control outcomes, with the entire modeled scope switching to its new operating rate three months after rollout approval. For a phased rollout, date each group separately and retain shared costs until the last dependency moves and billing ends.
Today's $210,000 annual operating cost comprises $110,000 for subscription and support, $35,000 for hosting and $65,000 for external services including connector maintenance. A $15,000 configuration project on the incumbent cuts annual services to $45,000, leaving annual operations at $190,000. For the full modeled scope, the C1 scenario assumes $60,000 upfront for transition. At steady state, a $135,000 subscription, $5,000 in residual hosting and $20,000 in retained services total $160,000 a year. The $60,000 transition and $160,000 annual run rate both cover the full modeled rollout.
During the first three months, each option incurs $52,500 at the existing run rate. For the remaining nine months of year one, the improved incumbent costs $142,500 to operate and the C1 proposal costs $120,000. Add the upfront investment, then two full years at each new rate. Rates stay flat, operating cash payments occur evenly each month, and the new subscription starts as the old payment obligation ends. The schedule shows undiscounted cash flows. For the renewal decision, compare the two right-hand columns to see what the additional C1 investment buys.
| Three-year cash schedule | Keep current | Improve incumbent | C1, full modeled scope |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront investment | $0 | $15,000 | $60,000 |
| Year 1 operations | $210,000 | $195,000 | $172,500 |
| Year 2 operations | $210,000 | $190,000 | $160,000 |
| Year 3 operations | $210,000 | $190,000 | $160,000 |
| Total cash cost | $630,000 | $590,000 | $552,500 |
Against unchanged spend, the C1 proposal saves $137,500 in operations over 33 months. After the $60,000 investment, the net cash benefit is $77,500. Dividing that benefit by the transition investment gives a 129.2% three-year return. Dividing the same benefit by the $630,000 cost of keeping the platform gives a 12.3% reduction in total cash cost. Payback comes 17.4 months from rollout approval, comprising three months before savings begin and 14.4 months to recover $60,000 at $50,000 per year.
The decision at renewal is closer. Compared with improving the incumbent, C1 requires $45,000 more upfront and costs $30,000 less per year after cutover. Over 33 months, that operating advantage adds up to $82,500. Subtract the additional investment and C1 comes out $37,500 ahead over three years. Its return on the additional $45,000 is 83.3%, with payback in month 21. This is the comparison to put on the funding request if the incumbent improvement is feasible.
Which assumptions could change the decision?#
The services agreement matters most. The base case cuts C1's annual services payments by $45,000 against today's $65,000 and by $25,000 against the improved incumbent's $45,000. If C1 still pays $65,000, add $123,750 for the 33 months after cutover. C1 then costs $676,250 over three years versus $590,000 if the incumbent improvement proceeds as planned. If the same contract prevents either reduction, the improved incumbent costs $645,000 and C1 costs $31,250 more.
Test timing separately. If only C1's cutover slips to month six, its three-year cost rises to $565,000, leaving a $25,000 advantage over the improved incumbent. Against unchanged spend, net benefit falls to $65,000 and payback moves to 20.4 months. If cutover stays on time but the entire old $110,000 subscription-and-support bundle remains payable for three additional months, add $27,500 once. C1 then costs $580,000, only $10,000 below the improved incumbent.
For the funding memo, replace even monthly payments with contractual payment dates. Annual prepayment can change when cash payback occurs. Apply Finance's discounting policy if it requires a present-value comparison. C1's identity modernization and rollout guide
What one access review can prove#
Choose an application with representative access decisions, a connector that can perform the required write action and an exception that needs an owner. From the last comparable campaign, collect elapsed days, specialist and reviewer hours, reminders, decisions completed, removals required and the share needing manual follow-up. Compare specialist hours per 100 decisions and the share of removals verified by the deadline. Before the pilot, agree with Finance and the control owner on the improvement and deadline adherence required for expansion.
In the pilot, follow a removal all the way through. C1 can route reviews, record decisions and produce remediation reports. Where the connector and permissions support automatic removal, check the resulting access in the target system. Send a manual exception to its owner and time the follow-up through verified closure. Include that work in the next estimate. C1's access review guide
DigitalOcean reported 85% less effort on its first 1,200 reviews across seven departments. Campaign hours give your team a way to test that same measure. If your pilot starts with requests, measure IT handling time per comparable ticket. Ramp reported 95% less IT effort processing access-request tickets after introducing request submission and approval routing through C1. DigitalOcean's review results · Ramp's access request results
Ask Finance to authorize a capped evaluation budget, name the IAM lead accountable and schedule the funding decision after the first campaign. Compare the pilot hours and verified removals with the agreed threshold and both proposals. If the results justify expansion, price the next group of applications using those rates, each application's expected decision volume, connector requirements and mix of exceptions. Finance can fund that group, keep C1 scoped to the pilot or pursue the incumbent improvement.
Before booking the $30,000 hosting reduction, have Infrastructure identify every application using the old resources, verify the last dependency has moved and confirm when billing stops. For the $45,000 services reduction, Procurement needs revised contract terms and an effective date. Update the cash schedule after each rollout group. At renewal, reconcile projected reductions to the commitments and invoices Finance will actually pay.
Frequently asked questions#
How do I calculate IGA ROI?#
Compare operating cash savings with the additional upfront cost over a stated period. If that cost is positive, subtract it from the savings, divide by the additional cost and multiply by 100. If it is zero or negative, show Finance the net cash flows for each option.
What does it cost to improve my current IGA platform?#
Start with renewal, hosting and services, then add the cost of configuring and validating the improvement. Deduct recurring expenses only from the date the team can actually reduce them.
How should Finance value hours saved on access reviews?#
Multiply verified hours released by the relevant loaded hourly rate and identify who will use the time. Record cash savings separately when payroll, overtime or supplier payments fall.
How does a later cutover affect payback?#
A delay postpones the first savings. If costs and savings rates otherwise stay the same, a three-month delay extends payback by three months. Additional overlap charges can extend it further.
How should we account for security risk?#
Track a control outcome such as overdue revocations, their age and evidence of closure. Present any estimate of financial exposure separately, with its assumptions and the risk owner's assessment.
Bring a campaign to your C1 demo#
Bring one recent access review, its control requirements and the cost baseline. Use them to identify which work C1 could take out of the next campaign and what evidence Finance would need to expand it. See modern IGA in action


